We think the answer is YES! There are many reasons to get bullish on oil and, even more so, oil stocks. One is the fact that many indicators are beginning to suggest an economic recovery could be in the cards over the next several months. The three largest consumers of oil including the United States, the European Union and China should start to see things stabilize and by the Q3 or Q4 of this year their economies should start to recover. This recovery will bring the world's economic engine back to life and oil consumption should start to increase again.
But while the price of oil has risen from the $30s to $50, oil stocks have not really rallied much. Below we highlight the ratio of oil stocks (S&P 500 Oil & Gas index) to oil (the commodity). When the line is rising, oil stocks are outperforming oil, and vice versa for a declining line. As shown below, when oil spiked in early 2008, the ratio dropped to its lowest level in years. Then when oil tanked in late 2008, the ratio spiked to its highest level in years as oil stocks held up much better. Recently, however, oil has rallied and oil stocks have been stagnant, causing the ratio to come back down. At the moment, the ratio is resting just above the average since 1990.
We feel the breakout that occurred in early 2009, and the current stabilization just above the 20 year average suggest oil stocks may once again outperform the price of the commodity.
In interviews with more than a dozen small-, mid- and large-cap portfolio managers, most said they were taking the initial months of 2009 to increase their exposure to energy stocks. Largely thanks to the spending spree currently ongoing in Washington, these managers expect all that cash to create an inflationary environment for energy prices down the road.